Output Gap
Live
Fiscal

UK Budget Introduces PDEL to Ringfence Preventive Spending

The UK Treasury has created a new preventative departmental expenditure limit, PDEL, to protect spending on early interventions ahead of a tough spending review, aiming to reduce long-term state costs.

The UK Treasury has created a new preventative departmental expenditure limit, PDEL, to protect spending on early...

The Treasury has introduced a new preventative departmental expenditure limit, PDEL, in the budget. This aims to ringfence spending on preventive policies ahead of what is described as an impossibly tough spending review next year.

Pronounced P-Del, the new category marks a potentially consequential addition to the government's fiscal framework. The chancellor, John Healey, announced the measure. The upcoming spending review could take place as late as the autumn. It will include a specific ringfence on prevention spending. The goal is to protect such expenditure to bring down future costs.

Background and context

The idea of PDEL has been discussed for years. Its introduction is seen as a welcome, if plucky, new character in the tax and spend universe. The thinktank Demos introduced the concept in a 2023 paper. It identified £22bn of government costs that could have been averted by preventive programmes.

Demos's chief executive, Polly Curtis, stated that for decades governments have talked about prevention but the system has consistently rewarded spending on crises instead of stopping them. The new PDEL category will sit alongside existing departmental expenditure limits. RDEL covers day-to-day resource spending, while CDEL covers capital investment.

The formal separation of day-to-day and investment spending was a Gordon Brown innovation. It allowed for the golden rule that borrowing should only fund investment. Demos argues that some day-to-day spending, while not strict investment, is worth protecting because cutting it brings short-term cash benefits but higher net costs over time.

Implications and potential impact

The shift to formally recognising preventive spending is gaining traction due to better data. Gavin Kelly, chief executive of the Nuffield Foundation, points to studies on Labour's Sure Start centres. The research showed they boosted children's education, increased future wages, and reduced hospital admissions.

The budget offered few details on how PDEL will be defined. The Treasury says departments must argue for individual projects to be considered preventive. Rough sleeping is one highlighted area. Early mental health support and obesity prevention are others.

Alan Milburn is poised to make a similar case in an upcoming review on young people not in education, employment or training. He will argue that money spent now on employment support saves future costs on welfare, health and housing.

If defined tightly, preventive spending could even be considered investment for fiscal rules purposes, though the Treasury says that is not the current plan. The Institute for Government has recommended a prevention ringfence for years. It suggests defining preventative spending and tracking progress over time, including primary, secondary, and tertiary interventions.

A challenging fiscal landscape

The move comes against a brutal fiscal backdrop. Whitehall departments were recently asked to cut future capital budgets to fund defence investment. The Institute for Fiscal Studies reckons there are £27bn-worth of spending pressures. The UK government has faced tight departmental funding settlements since 2010.

Tight budgets can lead to a cycle of increasing demand for acute services. You cannot ringfence your way out of all spending pressures. Yet the new PDEL category aims to break that cycle by protecting spending that prevents future crises. The spending review will formalise this ringfence, aiming to protect preventive spending and bring down long-term costs.

Related coverage

More from Fiscal