Healey's budget leaves £28bn fiscal gap, risks real-term cuts
Chancellor John Healey's first budget has left a £28bn shortfall in public finances, forcing a 'brutal' future spending review.

The UK government is facing pressure to explain how it will control rising welfare spending after Chancellor John Healey's first budget. Healey stuck to his fiscal rules with £15bn of headroom, but a £28bn shortfall now looms, setting the stage for difficult trade-offs between defence, welfare, and departmental budgets.
Healey initially told reporters 4's Today programme: 'There will be, there will be a reduction in the benefits bill, we'll do that in a Labour way.' The Chancellor also committed to spending 3% of economic output on defence by 2030. He later clarified, however, that the government was 'not setting an arbitrary target or timetable' for benefit reductions. Downing Street declined to say whether the ambition was to cut welfare spending below its current level or merely slow its projected growth.
The £23.6bn fiscal buffer left by former Chancellor Rachel Reeves has been eroded by rising borrowing costs. The Office for Budget Responsibility attributes much of the UK's projected economic growth to increased spending on health-related benefits and support for pensioners.
Welfare spending trajectory
The Institute for Fiscal Studies warned that Healey's budget failed to cover the £28bn shortfall needed to avoid a return to austerity. IFS director Helen Miller said avoiding real-terms cuts for unprotected departments could require a £17bn top-up for 2030-31. An additional £11bn is needed to fund the commitment to increase defence spending to 3% of GDP.
The OBR forecasts welfare spending will reach £353bn this year, an increase of £19bn, before rising to £431bn in 2031/32. Its breakdown for that year is as follows:
| Category | Forecast Spending (2031/32) |
|---|---|
| Pensioners (state pension, winter fuel) | £209.8bn |
| Universal Credit and legacy benefits | £110.7bn |
| Disability benefits (e.g., PIP) | £69.6bn |
The IFS criticised the Chancellor for deferring important decisions to next year's spending review. Ministers have already introduced measures aimed at curbing costs, including reinstating face-to-face assessments for benefits and tweaking Universal Credit rules.
Defence spending commitment
The Chancellor committed to 'fully funding' the £4.7 billion black hole in the defence investment plan left by the previous government. According to the Budget document, this shortfall will be met 'through reprioritisation of capital budgets' across government.
Departments will be asked to reduce their capital budgets by 1% each between 2027-28 and 2029-30 to raise roughly £3 billion. The remaining £1.7 billion will come from an 'unallocated contingency in the Treasury's capital reserve'. Healey signalled that departments would have to make further spending cuts to pay for choices made in next year's review.
Reaction from think-tanks and opposition
Think-tanks delivered a stark assessment of the budget's long-term challenges. The Resolution Foundation said the Chancellor had 'spread the jam thin'. Its chief executive, Ruth Curtice, said cost-of-living support was spread too thinly and would leave families facing higher energy bills than during the last price shock.
Helen Miller of the IFS said the budget had left the government facing a potential 'spending review that looks pretty brutal for some departments'. She added that the plan to reduce borrowing had been pushed back and that the 'raft of fiddly measures' would do little to boost growth.
Opposition parties were critical. Tory leader Kemi Badenoch said the Budget was 'not good enough, not strong enough, not bold enough'. Reform UK's Treasury spokesman Robert Jenrick described it as a 'nothing burger'. Conservative shadow chancellor Andrew Griffith argued the government could find money for defence by curbing the welfare bill, telling reporters: 'If your welfare bill is going up by £60 billion, and you're struggling to try and find £10 billion for defence.'
Medium-term pressures and next steps
Departmental spending plans for the rest of the parliament are broadly unchanged in cash terms, which implies real-terms cuts given inflation driven by global instability. Helen Miller said the government would be sceptical about delivering these implied cuts to other services. A clear short-term risk is another season of damaging speculation about tax rises next year.
The Chancellor warned the UK faces more 'hard decisions' about spending priorities. He told Good Morning Britain that funding the defence plan 'involved hard choices, it's reprioritising within Government'.
Healey raised taxes on banks and landlords to fund household energy relief, offering millions of households £100 to help with bills. Labour has promised there would be no return to austerity. The Budget will face closer scrutiny when the OBR and Resolution Foundation host a post-budget briefing, with the IFS also set to give its considered analysis. The Chancellor and Prime Minister Andy Burnham will seek to rally support for the Budget on a visit to a Rolls-Royce factory in the East Midlands.





