IMF urges UK to cut welfare over bank tax hikes
The IMF has advised Chancellor John Healey to target pensions and welfare savings rather than increase taxes on banks, citing the UK's high tax-to-GDP ratio. The call comes amid fierce debate over reversing a cut to the bank surcharge ahead of the October 28 Budget.

The International Monetary Fund has urged Chancellor John Healey to prioritise savings on pensions and welfare instead of increasing taxes on Britain’s banks. The IMF’s deputy director for Europe, Helge Berger, made the call during meetings in Bangkok, noting the UK’s tax-to-GDP ratio is historically high at roughly 40%.
Chancellor John Healey is set to deliver his first Budget on October 28 and is understood to be targeting the banking sector for additional revenue. He has warned the public to expect a tough fiscal statement. The most straightforward option available is reversing a prior cut to the banking surcharge, a move that could generate around £2 billion a year.
Sector warns of lending and competitiveness risks
City lobbyists and major bank groups have issued strong warnings. They caution that higher bank taxes could throttle lending, harm economic growth, and force some lenders to move jobs and operations abroad. A letter from UK Finance chief executive David Postings to the Chancellor and the prime minister stated that reversing the surcharge cut would reduce annual UK GDP by £1.2 billion in real terms by 2029-30. The same letter warned banks would issue £10.4 billion less in business loans and mortgages in that period if the surcharge remained at 3%.
Smaller tax charges in rival financial centres like Frankfurt, Dublin, and Amsterdam are cited as a key risk. Jamie Dimon of JP Morgan said in May he could scrap plans for a new £3 billion London headquarters if the UK government becomes hostile toward banks. Louise Hellem of the CBI urged avoiding sector-specific taxation, citing the banking sector's already high tax rate relative to international peers.
Fiscal data shows sector profitability and tax burden
Major UK banks have reported substantial profits, fueling the political debate. The four largest lenders, HSBC, NatWest, Barclays, and Lloyds, reported £29.2 billion in profits in the first six months of this year, with £13.7 billion pledged to investors via dividends and share buybacks. Over the past five years, those four banks have earned £200 billion in pre-tax profits.
Despite this profitability, industry figures show the existing tax burden is significant. Analysis from PwC reveals that total taxes on UK banks amount to 46% of profits, a higher rate than in several key European hubs.
| Financial Centre | Total Tax as % of Profits |
|---|---|
| UK | 46% |
| Amsterdam | 42% |
| Frankfurt | 39% |
| Dublin | 29% |
The TUC estimates the 2023 cut to the bank surcharge has already cost the Treasury £6 billion in revenue over three years. The union body calls for increasing the surcharge to 16%, projecting £24 billion in tax revenue over four years. Campaigners at Positive Money claim a windfall tax on lenders' profits could raise £19 billion from the four largest banks alone.
Policy options and political debate intensify
The Chancellor is facing pressure from multiple sides. He has faced fierce lobbying from the left of the Labour party and trade unions to impose higher taxes on the sector following bumper bank profits. Conversely, Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch joined those opposing a bank tax earlier this week, firing a warning shot at Healey during a visit to Edinburgh. Shadow chancellor Andrew Griffith said a raid on the financial services sector would stifle growth.
Policy proposals vary. The Institute for Public Policy Research recommends a temporary surcharge on bank windfall profits to raise £1 billion. Author Philip Augar said banks, enjoying boom conditions due to high interest rates, have broader shoulders than others and that a moderate tax increase could raise £2 billion to £3 billion annually. The IMF's Helge Berger suggested reforming property taxes or VAT as alternatives to bank taxes for additional revenue.
Economists have predicted that Healey's fiscal headroom has been cut by more than half since spring, partly due to inflationary pressures. The chief executives of HSBC, Lloyds, NatWest, Barclays and Santander were summoned to a meeting with Healey last week, where the Chancellor cautioned of the challenging fiscal landscape but kept his cards close to his chest. His decision on the bank surcharge reversal will be announced in the October 28 Budget.





