Output Gap
Live
Labour market

Labour's regulatory overhaul faces business and union scrutiny

The Labour government is advancing a major pro-regulation agenda while pledging to cut business compliance costs, a dual approach drawing both support and skepticism from industry and unions.

The Labour government is advancing a major pro-regulation agenda while pledging to cut business compliance costs, a dual...

Labour is advancing sweeping regulatory reforms under new leadership, with pledges to end decades of neoliberalism and simplify business compliance. Prime Minister Andy Burnham pledged to end 40 years of neoliberalism before taking office. The party's Employment Rights Act represents the most significant increase in workers' rights in a generation. Shadow chancellor Andrew Griffith said 'Labour have finally admitted that endless red tape is hammering businesses and killing jobs across the country'. Chancellor John Healey acknowledged British firms are 'fed up with form-filling and pointless paperwork' eating into time and money. Proposed changes, announced ahead of Healey's first Budget on Wednesday, aim to make compliance guidance easier and simplify reporting rules. The government has set itself a target of cutting regulation by 25% by the end of the current Parliament. Burnham and Healey are expected to meet some business leaders on Friday at No 10 North.

Government cost-saving measures face union skepticism

The Treasury's £800m savings target through reduced bureaucracy is contested by unions warning of safety risks from staff cuts. Ministers claim cutting 'pointless paperwork' will save businesses almost £800m in administrative and tariff costs. Mike Clancy of the Prospect union urged the government to ditch its promise to cut the regulatory administrative burden by 25%. He argued that regulators are vital for safety and environmental protection. Regulators continue to be labelled as 'blockers' despite the vital work they do keeping us safe and protecting our natural environment, Clancy said. The union warned of risks from staff cuts. In the privatised water sector, multiple regulators like Ofwat and the Environment Agency operate, yet none are responsible for drawing up a coherent plan for the sector.

Historical regulatory context shapes current debate

The political narrative around red tape draws on decades of rhetoric from both major parties. The phrase originated from the tape used to tie government bills and was popularised by historian Thomas Carlyle. Conservative governments have long championed deregulation. Thatcher's 'big bang' deregulation drive unleashed the City. John Major was enthusiastic about 'hacking back the jungle of red tape'. Michael Heseltine coined the term 'bonfire of red tape'. Gordon Brown celebrated a light-touch regulatory regime for the financial sector until the 2008 crisis. More recently, Boris Johnson campaigned on unfettering businesses from 'Brussels bureaucracy' and mentioned 'bendy bananas'. Business groups have said they preferred complying with EU standards over adopting new UK regimes after Brexit. Labour's own Rachel Reeves once referred to regulation as a 'boot on the neck' of British business.

The government issued a press release promising to 'slash the red tape choking firms'. The article argues that embracing this idea is unlikely to help the government make the case for more stringent regulation, which it views as essential. Good regulation, such as a robust competition regime, is necessary for markets to work well. The neoliberal illusion that privatisation liberated markets from state interference obscures the state's continued control through regulatory agencies. The CBI's Chief Executive Rain Newton Smith welcomed the plans but said the test would be in delivering reform. Prime Minister Andy Burnham said 'pointless bureaucracy gets in the way' of hard-working people building their businesses.

Related coverage

More from Labour market