Output Gap
Live

2018 19 Government Shutdown

Origin and history

The 2018-2019 Government Shutdown originated in the United States federal government. It was a single, continuous lapse in appropriations that began in late December 2018 and extended into January 2019. This event was the third shutdown to occur during the 2018 calendar year, but it became the longest federal shutdown in U.S. history by duration. The shutdown was precipitated by a political impasse between the Congressional Democrats, who controlled the House of Representatives, and President Donald Trump's administration. The central point of contention was the administration's demand for over five billion dollars in congressional appropriations to fund a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border. When Congress did not approve the funding, a lapse in appropriations for several key federal departments and agencies was triggered. This specific shutdown is historically notable for its extended length, which surpassed the prior record set by the 1995-1996 shutdown, and for its concentrated impact on a specific set of government functions.

What it is for

A government shutdown in the United States is a mechanism that occurs when there is a failure to enact legislation to fund government operations and agencies. It is not a designed policy tool but rather a consequential outcome of the congressional appropriations process. The 2018-2019 shutdown specifically resulted from the failure to pass appropriations bills or a continuing resolution for departments including Homeland Security, Justice, State, Agriculture, and others. Its primary operational effect was to furlough, or send home without pay, non-essential federal employees from these departments. Essential employees, such as those in national security and public safety roles, were required to work without immediate pay until funding was restored. The shutdown also forced the suspension of many non-critical government services, from national park maintenance to certain regulatory and research functions, effectively placing parts of the federal government in a state of stasis.

Pros and cons

There are no inherent "pros" to a government shutdown as it is a breakdown of normal governance, though some political actors may perceive strategic advantages. A significant con is the immediate financial and psychological hardship imposed on hundreds of thousands of federal employees and contractors who must work without pay or are furloughed. This event disrupts vital public services, from food safety inspections and airport security operations to scientific research and housing assistance, creating broad public inconvenience and potential risk. Economists widely agree that even temporary shutdowns have a negative, albeit usually modest, aggregate effect on economic growth and consumer confidence. A common mistake is underestimating the cascading effects on government contractors and the businesses that rely on federal workers' spending, which extends the economic pain beyond the public sector. Many who initially support a shutdown as a political tactic come to regret it as the human and operational costs become publicly evident and pressure to resolve the impasse mounts.

Who it suits

A government shutdown does not "suit" any group in a practical sense, as it is universally disruptive. However, it is a tactic that can be employed by political factions who believe the issue at stake justifies the collateral damage and who calculate they can withstand the public backlash. It may be seen as suitable for political actors with a firm base of support who are willing to use the operation of government as a bargaining chip to achieve a specific policy goal. The 2018-2019 shutdown particularly suited an administration and its allies who were determined to highlight border security as a paramount issue and who believed demonstrating a willingness to force a crisis would strengthen their negotiating position. Conversely, it is profoundly unsuitable for federal employees, contractors, citizens reliant on suspended services, and the broader economy. The strategy is generally ill-suited for political groups concerned with stable governance or those whose constituents are disproportionately harmed by the cessation of specific federal functions.

Latest 2018 19 Government Shutdown news

Latest reporting